- C V STARR INTERMEDIATE SCHOOL — Grades 3–5 · 664 students
- JOHN F KENNEDY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL — Grades PK–2 · 592 students
- HENRY H WELLS MIDDLE SCHOOL — Grades 6–8 · 656 students
- BREWSTER HIGH SCHOOL — Grades 9–12 · 1,076 students
| Metric | Brewster Central School District | National Average | Comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Student Enrollment | 2,966 | 3,700 | ↓ Smaller than avg |
| Number of Schools | 4 | 6 | Varies by district |
| Per-Pupil Spending | $26,900/yr (est.) | $13,700/yr | State avg est. |
| District Type | Public School District | Public District | — |
| Overall Rating | 4/10 — Below Average | — | Below average |
| District | Rating | Percentile | Students |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brewster Central School District (this district) | 4/10 | 39th | 2,966 |
| Briarcliff Manor Union Free School District | 10/10 | 99th | 1,350 |
| Bedford Central School District | 8/10 | 78th | 3,627 |
| Hendrick Hudson Central School District | 7/10 | 68th | 2,214 |
🔢 Show the math behind this rating
Ranked against 577 rated districts in NY → 39th percentile → 4/10.
Source: New York State Education Dept, 2023–24 Grades 3–8 ELA & Math assessments. Full methodology →
About Brewster Central School District
Zip code 10509 in Brewster Central, New York is served by Brewster Central School District for public school enrollment. The district covers grades Kindergarten – 12th. This page provides a data-driven overview of Brewster Central School District’s funding levels, size, rating, and what families should know before enrolling or making a housing decision in this area.
Funding and Resources
Public school districts in New York spend approximately $26,900 per student per year on average (state-level estimate; district-level figures vary), well above the national average (U.S. average: $13,700/year). Districts at this funding level typically offer smaller class sizes, broader elective and extracurricular programs, stronger technology infrastructure, and more competitive teacher salaries. Per-pupil spending directly affects teacher compensation, class sizes, elective course offerings, technology access, and the depth of student support services — making it one of the most meaningful structural indicators of district capacity.
District Scale and Program Breadth
With 4 schools, Brewster Central School District operates as a mid-sized district serving students from Kindergarten – 12th. Mid-sized districts strike a balance between community-scale relationships and sufficient program breadth. Most offer core academic tracks, basic extracurricular programs, and adequate student support services.
Understanding the 4/10 Rating
Brewster Central School District has earned an overall SchoolDistrictFinder rating of 4/10, placing it in the below average tier. Our ratings are based on state assessment results — the share of students scoring proficient or above in reading and math, as reported in New York State’s Grades 3–8 ELA & Math assessments (2023–24 school year). We average each district’s reading and math proficiency, then rank it against other districts in the same state to produce a 1–10 score. Because New York is compared only against itself, the rating reflects how this district performs relative to its in-state peers.
Brewster Central School District falls near the middle of New York on state assessment results, with reading and math proficiency close to the state median. Average-rated districts provide foundational public education, and many families find they deliver solid day-to-day learning — particularly when parents stay engaged. If you're considering this area, look beyond the overall rating: visit schools, talk to current parents, and research the specific school your child would attend. Average districts often have individual schools that significantly outperform the district mean.
Enrollment for Families in Zip Code 10509
Children in zip code 10509 are assigned to Brewster Central School District for public school enrollment, covering grades Kindergarten – 12th. School assignments are address-specific — your elementary, middle, and high school placements depend on your exact street address within zip code 10509, not just your neighborhood. Two homes on opposite ends of the same zip code may be assigned to different schools within the same district.
To confirm your specific school assignments, contact Brewster Central School District at (845)279-8000 or visit www.brewsterschools.org. Typical enrollment documents include proof of residency (lease or deed plus a utility bill), your child’s birth certificate, current immunization records, and prior school records. If your child has an IEP or 504 plan, bring that documentation to enrollment — New York districts are required to continue services within a reasonable period. Fall enrollment windows typically open in late winter or early spring; contact the district for exact dates and required steps.
School Districts and Home Values in Brewster Central
School district quality is one of the most consistent factors in residential home pricing. Because Brewster Central School District serves zip code 10509, buyers should factor school district quality into their overall evaluation of homes in zip code 10509. District boundaries are address-specific — verify the exact district assignment for any property you’re seriously considering rather than assuming based on the neighborhood. A single block can place two adjacent homes in different districts with different ratings and different annual property tax implications.
Use the property tax estimator on this page to calculate estimated annual tax obligations based on your target purchase price. In New York, property taxes are a primary funding source for public schools — your tax payments directly support Brewster Central School District programs and staff. Understanding both district quality and the associated tax burden is essential financial due diligence before committing to any home in zip code 10509.
Data Sources and Accuracy
All district information on this page is sourced from the NCES Common Core of Data (CCD) 2024–2025, the U.S. Department of Education’s annual census of all public school districts — the same dataset used by researchers, journalists, and policymakers to analyze American public education. District boundaries, school assignments, phone numbers, and per-pupil expenditure figures are updated annually when NCES publishes new data, typically in spring. Always verify your specific school assignment and enrollment requirements directly with Brewster Central School District before making any housing or enrollment decision based on zip code 10509 data.